Hart's doing well then!

[Swiss]

http://sport.bt.com/beautiful-game/torino-to-drop-error-prone-hart-91364173612449

[goat]

whatever happened to the hart fanclub on here?

[Swiss]

I still like him, was sorry to see him go without Pep trying with him. Was sorry to see Bravo having a mare of a season n'all!

Will always be remembered fondly by me: Though we said it since he was a kid, his catching & distribution never improved. Now his mistakes are looking more David James like, or worse!

[Neil Mcnab]

 He is better than what we have now, but that is not saying much. No one is going to be paying the big money he got from us, so he might get a golden goodbye on a knock down fee as well.

[gavin]

Decent keeper but I can see why he doesn't fit in with Pep. We're gonna need another new keeper in the summer. Joe should find a decent club but he might have to accept a pay cut. I'm sure he should be able to afford it.

[bluebrendan]

whatever happened to the hart fanclub on here?

I was never a great Hart fan but people in glass houses and all that, goat - you rated Isaksson. 

[Gareth]

"Hart's doing well then!"

And do we take amusement from this? He's not the world's greatest but he played his part in two league-winning teams and even I can see that he's better than either of our current keepers. Didn't some people describe him as "just a shot-stopper"? Presumably that was before they realised that shot-stopping didn't appear on Bravo's CV. Clearly there's no future for him at City, he knows that, but is there any reason why we shouldn't wish him well?

[goat]

fair enough i spose

[KunDB]

Spot on Gareth.

We all knew and discussed Joe's weaknesses frequently but he was City through and through. He also responded last summer to his disappointment with great dignity. So I for one wish him all the best.

[gavin]

I wish him all the best and respect him as a City legend. However it is worth pointing out that he has problems amongst all the vitriol aimed at Bravo.

[Gareth]

I wish him all the best and respect him as a City legend. However it is worth pointing out that he has problems amongst all the vitriol aimed at Bravo.

My post was not intended to be vitriolic, sorry you took it that way. But I really do think we need a better 'keeper if we want to be a top side. And whatever problems Joe may have, I don't think they are City's problems any more. So I think I can overlook them now and respect his achievements. I hope he'd be a welcome visitor back at the Etihad whenever that might be.   

[gavin]

I didn't take it that way, I was referring to what I hear at most matches unfortunately. However, I'm sure that Claudio has saves on his CV over the years or he wouldn't have had the career he has had.

[Gareth]

Be great for everyone if he got his career back on track.

[goat]

easy to say we need a top keeper...hell of a lot harder to get one

i say break the bank and legs for neuer,  anyone want to chip in, he might cost a few quid

[Gareth]

What I think about that is, take a positive view and say it turns out after all that Stones can actually play; the money spent on him would still be wasted if we didn't similarly invest in a half-decent 'keeper. It's not my money, but if we're in it to compete at the top level, we can't do it in a half-arsed way. Not many great teams that couldn't defend properly when required. And I mean defend... can't play the ball out from the back of the net.

[Swiss]

What about Donnarumma?


He 'could' be one of the top keepers for 20 years (He's 18) and any exhorbitant amount could be saved on the potential longevity.

Neuer is already 31 and by the same standard as above, could be here for 7 years.

Neuer Stats

Donnarumma Stats

Both would be massive fees and hard to prize away from their clubs.

[zacc]

I didn't take it that way, I was referring to what I hear at most matches unfortunately. However, I'm sure that Claudio has saves on his CV over the years or he wouldn't have had the career he has had.

bet they  can be counted on one hand just not his!!

[Swiss]

Stat-wise, 14/15 was his Bravo's season out of the last few (data doesn't go too far back).

Barce__________________City
14/15_________________16/17
37 appearances (Domestic) 21
23 clean sheets 5
0.51 goals conceded per game 1.24
3.47 saves per goal 1.04
1.59 average saves per match 1.24
83% distribution success 75%

[goat]

What about Donnarumma?


He 'could' be one of the top keepers for 20 years (He's 18) and any exhorbitant amount could be saved on the potential longevity.

Neuer is already 31 and by the same standard as above, could be here for 7 years.

Neuer Stats

Donnarumma Stats

Both would be massive fees and hard to prize away from their clubs.

milan have new owners, not sure they would flog the star man so quickly

[Swiss]

I forgot they have new owners.

But will Bayern be equally as happy to sell?

It would take a world record bid for either i imagine

[Paddy]

Should have opted for Kaspar when we had the chance, far superior to Joe

[gavin]

Conceded 5 this weekend and has made the second most mistakes that lead to goals of all keepers in serie a.

http://sport.bt.com/beautiful-game/joe-hart-has-another-torino-horror-show-91364180378548

[bluebrendan]

Should have opted for Kaspar when we had the chance, far superior to Joe

Debatable but even if he is he's still not good enough.

[nimrod]

Pep shipping him out was a very public humiliation
He's lost confidence

With goalies and strikers it's all about confidence

[goat]

he was doing that shit before pep gandalf

[Swiss]

Shame. I'll have fond memories but both club and player need to move on.

I'm hoping donnarummer comes :-D

[nimrod]

he was doing that shit before pep gandalf

Some yeah but he was better than Norman Wisdom

Anyway I blame pep for us being a bit shit this season