News:

When using this site you agree to cookies being used to support forum functions only.

Main Menu

100 Top Prog albums

Started by nimrod, May 29, 2015, 00:01:45

Previous topic - Next topic

nimrod

might be of interest to the scores of progrock fans on here

(may give Goaty bollocks a hard on)  :D

http://powerofprog.com/notes/Prog_Magazine%3A_100_Greatest_Prog_Albums_Of_All_Time

goat


reddishblue

There's only 1 winner. Hot Rats.


shandon

I have the Radiohead and Beatles album each mentioned, as well as one of the Pink Floyd albums.

bluebrendan

I was surprised to see a Supertramp album in the list, I would never really have classed them as prog rock.


nimrod

Quote from: bluebrendan on May 29, 2015, 10:33:51
I was surprised to see a Supertramp album in the list, I would never really have classed them as prog rock.

Yeah very proggy Brendo, they did some pop stuff like Breakfast In America but a lot of their album stuff is proggy

BongoBlue

#7
Quote from: nimrod on May 29, 2015, 14:18:53
Quote from: bluebrendan on May 29, 2015, 10:33:51
I was surprised to see a Supertramp album in the list, I would never really have classed them as prog rock.

Yeah very proggy Brendo, they did some pop stuff like Breakfast In America but a lot of their album stuff is proggy

Best Supertramp album is "Crime of the Century" imo which is on that list.

I have a few of the Floyd albums (Dark Side, Wish You were Here and Animals) as well. And Radiohead. Didn't know that I was that much of a prog back in the day.
(I did balance it out however with a healthy dose of Sex Pistols, Clash, Buzzcocks etc...)  ;)

nimrod

Its a bit silly this list though, its as if Italian & German prog didnt exist

reddishblue

After a quick view I've had at one time or another about 18 of them.  No albums left thanks to an acrimonious divorce.

I keep them in cloud now  :D

reddishblue

This wasn't on the list


goat


reddishblue

0. Hope have you this though and no greenday or blur ffs.


goat

i did have that

i dont mind blur, were better than fucking oasis

BongoBlue

Quote from: goat on May 30, 2015, 22:06:37
http://www.punknews.org/article/21079/kerrang-posts-list-of-top-50-punk-albums-of-all-time

bit old but punk has been shit for years anyway

a better score of 19 for me

That's more like it. Had a few of those. Glad to see Stiff Little Fingers in there; seminal band. A few left out though but overall pretty good.

bluepill

opeth! didn't expect to see that in there. Solid prog metal that band!

close to the edge is pretty class though Bill Bruford - bit of a ledge.

Swiss

The Bevis and Butthead sound track was a great program album

nimrod

Quote from: Swiss on June 18, 2015, 13:24:12
The Bevis and Butthead sound track was a great program album

:D

Didnt I meet you at a Yes gig once Swiss  :o

Yes have become a joke of a band nowadays, they hired a (frontman/singer) Jon Anderson soundalike/lookalike from a Yes tribute band for their world tour and latest album, Jon was ill at the time apparently, they didnt tell him, just did it.

Prog is still alive but I dont like anything after about 1978, either from new prog bands (like Dream Theatre) or old prog bands (like King Crimson), old farts like me just seem to like the classic stuff, of which there is thousands of albums in existence, prog in the 70's was a massive worldwide thing, bigger than most people think, Im only just hearing stuff from Russia and South America from the 70's

Anyway, speaking of Yes, Ive never heard anyone play keyboards as well as Rick Wakeman although Keith Emerson (ELP) does come close, listen to his piano on this unplugged gig




nimrod

Who remembers this famous song by The Carpenters, not many know it was written as an album track by 70's prog band Klaatu


ignore the first 40 seconds


Swiss

Maybe in a former life... I'm 32!

nimrod

Quote from: Swiss on June 21, 2015, 10:31:33
Maybe in a former life... I'm 32!

wish to fuck I was  :(

The Blue Blooded Maniac


Lekos

Can you handle your drink yet?

The Blue Blooded Maniac

I shall consume until I do! :p

nimrod

Rick Wakeman is the craziest fucker, he's done some insane shit

But I just heard him say when he played on Bowie's hit, Life On Mars, he got 9 quid eventually for it

Great song though and great piano





nimrod

This is a laugh, Bill Bailey banging on about progs top 10

elf's, goblins, wizards all in search of the lost chord  :D



Stephen Paul


goat

are you turning into mark e smith stevie?

Stephen Paul

Used to listen to the crap when I was stoned ffs

goat

no fuckin clue what you are on about  :D

you listened to punk stoned or the wizard and owl shit?

Stephen Paul


goat


Stephen Paul



bluemax138

It's gratifying to see that I'm not a complete philistine owning as I do 9 of the albums on that list.

Yes - Close To The Edge
Pink Floyd - Dark Side of the Moon / Wish You Were Here / The Wall
Rush - Moving Pictures / 2112 / Hemispheres / A Farewell To Kings / Permanent Waves.