News:

When using this site you agree to cookies being used to support forum functions only.

Main Menu

City v QPR (ah memories)

Started by 93:2012, May 10, 2015, 12:32:28

Previous topic - Next topic

goat

Quote from: bluebrendan on May 10, 2015, 20:30:32
Quote from: gavin on May 10, 2015, 20:20:04
Enjoyable game and that is the main thing. There was some wonderful football played and some absolutely dreadful defending - mainly from QOR but also from City. When Sergio has a few games in him and starts reaching form there is only Messi and Tranny above him in the world.

I would only put Messi ahead of him as the fake Ronaldo is an ex-rag and a whiny moaning twot to boot.

id have the lad with the nose ahead of aguero with the other two

bluebrendan

Quote from: goat on May 10, 2015, 22:19:29
Quote from: bluebrendan on May 10, 2015, 20:30:32
Quote from: gavin on May 10, 2015, 20:20:04
Enjoyable game and that is the main thing. There was some wonderful football played and some absolutely dreadful defending - mainly from QOR but also from City. When Sergio has a few games in him and starts reaching form there is only Messi and Tranny above him in the world.

I would only put Messi ahead of him as the fake Ronaldo is an ex-rag and a whiny moaning twot to boot.

id have the lad with the nose ahead of aguero with the other two

He's past it now.  ;D

goat

says the man thats past it


as an all round player he has more to his game

nimrod

Quote from: TrickyTrev on May 10, 2015, 14:54:05
Milner is decent, wtf are you guys on about?

some of those crosses 1st half were abysmal, he runs around a lot but devoid of real talent, we need better

would he get anywhere near a top team like Barca or Bayern - No

why play him on the wing when you have Navas on the bench?

Sorry but the engineer baffles me (and sorry I dont rate Milner)



Lekos

I like Milner - he gets a bad rep.  OK, he's not the most skillful player at the Club, but commitment wise I'd only put Zab and Kun above him...maybe Kompany also.

He's a fantastic utility player and should have started more games for us this season.  I'd sooner start Milner than Fernando / Nasri.

PS - We'll miss him when he's gone.

clevblue

Quote from: Lekos on May 11, 2015, 08:32:41

PS - We'll miss him when he's gone.

Surely that depends on who comes in? We all know he's a worker but we know we need more workers in most areas. This season, Milner has sometimes been the only one trying,  or so it's seemed. He has good and bad points definitely

nimrod

Quote from: Lekos on May 11, 2015, 08:32:41
I like Milner - he gets a bad rep.  OK, he's not the most skillful player at the Club, but commitment wise I'd only put Zab and Kun above him...maybe Kompany also.

He's a fantastic utility player and should have started more games for us this season.  I'd sooner start Milner than Fernando / Nasri.

PS - We'll miss him when he's gone.

He's a 100% er for sure

I just dont like it when he's in the team, granted though he is a decent utility player, anyway he obviously doesnt want to play for City next season ashe has refused to sign a new contract so I dont really see the commitment angle

The Blue Blooded Maniac

He's said he wants to stay but he needs assurance that he's going to play more games and Pele can't give him that.

goat

of course he wants to stay, nobody else is going to pay him what city does

nimrod

Quote from: Durk on May 11, 2015, 11:20:57
He's said he wants to stay but he needs assurance that he's going to play more games and Pele can't give him that.

surely if he was committed to MCFC he would sign

no player (except maybe our best players) is assured of playing a minimum No of games, what if he loses form half way through the season, does Pelle keep his promise?

surely commitment to a club is signing and putting in the effort so the mgr cant leave you out


alexsam

Hasn't Milner already agreed to go to the Dippers as a replacement for Stevie G.

Him and Henderson in the middle. Its the future.

Rowley Birkin QC

Quote from: clevblue on May 11, 2015, 09:45:48
Quote from: Lekos on May 11, 2015, 08:32:41

PS - We'll miss him when he's gone.

Surely that depends on who comes in?

Trouble with that - is City don't have the best of records on that score

Remember when everyone expected us to replace De Jong "with someone better"?

Lekos

Quote from: nimrod on May 11, 2015, 11:16:19
Quote from: Lekos on May 11, 2015, 08:32:41
I like Milner - he gets a bad rep.  OK, he's not the most skillful player at the Club, but commitment wise I'd only put Zab and Kun above him...maybe Kompany also.

He's a fantastic utility player and should have started more games for us this season.  I'd sooner start Milner than Fernando / Nasri.

PS - We'll miss him when he's gone.

He's a 100% er for sure

I just dont like it when he's in the team, granted though he is a decent utility player, anyway he obviously doesnt want to play for City next season ashe has refused to sign a new contract so I dont really see the commitment angle

I mean when on the pitch.  He wants to start more games, and who can blame him.  He'll take a wage drop to play for the 'dippers, but he'll get regular games.


Ludo

Quote from: nimrod on May 10, 2015, 23:50:43

why play him on the wing when you have Navas on the bench?

Probably because Navas is worse. He'd give a headless chicken a bad name.

Tricky Trev

#54
Quote from: nimrod on May 10, 2015, 23:50:43
Quote from: TrickyTrev on May 10, 2015, 14:54:05
Milner is decent, wtf are you guys on about?

some of those crosses 1st half were abysmal, he runs around a lot but devoid of real talent, we need better

would he get anywhere near a top team like Barca or Bayern - No

why play him on the wing when you have Navas on the bench?

Sorry but the engineer baffles me (and sorry I dont rate Milner)

Just like De Jong, under appreciated. And although he is not that flashy skillful player that can win a game alone, he is a very important work horse that every team needs. We can't have a team full of silva's. Real talent, what a load of horse shit.

He deserves to start more games, so leaving would be a good move.

KunDB

Arsenal played with real intent tonight showing how desperate they were to get second in PL. Still fell short losing to a soft Swansea goal (given by goal line technology).

Second place is now resting in our own hands again.

nimrod



everybody reckons Milner is underrated but everybody rates him highly

:D

Lekos

I think your use of the term "everybody" is quite loose  :D

Ludo

There's no doubt City could buy a better player but there's also no doubt we're abetter team at the minute with Milner in it.